top of page
etty-fidele-pwHNzvxVvnM-unsplash.jpg

Black Girls' Pushout & Criminalization in Schools

Data Hub

The premier home for comprehensive research, analysis, & data about school pushout and the factors that lead to the criminalization of Black girls & gender-expansive youth.
Data to empower policymakers, practitioners, & advocates to put into place evidence-informed solutions that enhance the safety and wellbeing of Black girls & gender-expansive youth.

Across the United States, schools use various punitive discipline practices that result in students being removed from class, such as suspensions, expulsions, transfers to an alternative education setting, or referrals to law enforcement. These practices weaken students’ connection with school by depriving students of valuable learning time and creating an environment that erodes students’ well-being and sense of safety at school. These students often end up pushed out of school altogether, as research shows that punitive discipline practices are associated with poor student achievement and a failure to complete school.

 

This kind of disconnection from school creates pathways to contact with the juvenile and criminal legal systems. These school-to-confinement pathways disproportionately affect students of color, especially Black girls. To disrupt school-to-confinement pathways, schools must address the disciplinary practices that drive school pushout.

National Snapshot of Discipline Trends Among Black Girls

Examining national disciplinary trends among girls[1] in public schools across four school years between 2011 and 2018, we see that Black girls were the only group of girls to be overrepresented in every type of disciplinary action. Despite a relatively stagnant enrollment share among female students of about 15% across all four years of data, Black girls accounted for more than three times their enrollment share in transfers (47%) and corporal punishment (47%) and more than two times their enrollment share in expulsions (43%) in the 2017-18 school year.

Black Girls
National pushout trends - 2024 v2 - Black girls.png

Here we use data from the U.S. Department of Education's Civil Rights Data Collection (CRDC) from 2011- 2018 to understand the impact of school discipline sanctions on girls. The data is filterable by state, race & ethnicity, and school year. 

Referrals to Law Enforcement

School-Related Arrests

Transfers

Explusions

In-School Suspensions

Out-of-School Suspensions

Restraints

Corporal Punishment

Seclusion

Notes

[1] When we use the term “girls,” we intend this to be inclusive of cisgender girls, nonbinary, gender non-conforming, genderqueer, and any girl-identified students. However, it is important to note the CRDC data uses binary male/female categories to capture sex, not gender identity.​

Note 1

Comments

Contact Dr. Janaé Bonsu-Love with questions or comments.

Acknowledgments

Data analysis and visualizations by Dr. Janaé Bonsu-Love and Khaila Mickens.​
Go back icons created by Freepik - Flaticon

Last updated: September 2024

bottom of page