top of page

Time to address the incarceration of Black disabled women and girls

Writer: Khaila Mickens
Khaila Mickens
28 minutes ago
7 min read


Removed from loved ones and preexisting care networks, the conditions of incarceration are disabling in and of themselves. Many people develop disabilities and health issues while incarcerated that they likely would not have developed outside. For instance, heat exposure, rampant overcrowding, chronic stress, and limited access to healthcare all contribute to long term health deficits. Research suggests that incarceration shortens life expectancy and contributes to poorer health outcomes later in life. For the many who are incarcerated with preexisting disabilities, the conditions have an even larger impact on their health and wellbeing.


Black women and girls with disabilities experience unique and elevated harms while incarcerated. While the topics of disability, criminalization, and their intersection often focus on the experiences of men and boys, incarcerated women and girls report disabilities and chronic illnesses at higher rates than incarcerated men in jails and prisons. A recent notable effort to critically engage with the experiences of incarcerated disabled women is this report from the Carceral State Project focusing on the Women’s Huron Valley Correctional Facility in Michigan. The report, which I highly recommend reading, includes detailed stories about disabled Black women currently or formerly incarcerated at the facility and the strategies they have used to resist inhumane conditions. 


For disabled Black women, girls, and gender expansive people, incarceration magnifies many of the harms and issues experienced outside: limited accommodations, issues accessing adequate health care, and, often as a direct result of these, isolation. Furthermore, the conditions of incarceration, already generally disabling, have an outsized impact on people with disabilities. 


Conditions of confinement for detained Black women with disabilities


Accommodations and Access

The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) is a law that “prohibits discrimination against people with disabilities in everyday activities.” It applies to nearly every institution in the United States, and criminal legal entities are not exempt. Further guidance for criminal justice agencies on the ADA website highlights that these agencies are required to “give people with disabilities equal opportunities and benefits as those given to people who do not have disabilities” by “modifying policies, practices, and procedures, providing physical access to buildings, and providing communication aids and services,” among other things. This means that appropriate accommodations should be provided that allow incarcerated people with disabilities equal access to programming, education, recreation, etc. In practice, unfortunately, this is often not the case.


Black women and girls with disabilities that require accommodations (such as mobility devices) often go through extraordinarily long approval processes. And if approved, that approval can still be rescinded at any time and, seemingly, for any reason. Brenda Charity, a 71-year-old woman, had been using a walker and wheelchair since the beginning of her sentence, and needed them to walk. The Denver Women’s Correctional Facility saw her using the elliptical and using light weights – a recommendation from her doctor on the outside – and used this to justify taking away her mobility devices. At the Women’s Huron Valley Correctional Facility, Julia Wigley reported that the prison “revoked the wheelchair accommodations for approximately 300 women” after she contacted an ADA investigator about there being a shortage of wheelchair aides at the prison. The facility claimed that the wheelchair accommodations had never been approved. However, the very presence of wheelchairs at the facility makes this unlikely, if not impossible.


Education in Confinement

In general, student access to education suffers in juvenile detention. Students are often taught by uncertified teachers, receive less educational services like credit recovery and advanced coursework, and are provided with fewer instructional hours. Students with disabilities, who comprise up to 85% of youth in juvenile detention, face further challenges to education access. All public education providers, including juvenile detention facilities, are subject to the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), a law requiring that special education services and accommodations be provided to all students with disabilities to ensure access to a “free and appropriate public education” (FAPE) in the “least restrictive environment.” 


However, current evidence suggests that juvenile detention facilities violate IDEA in various ways that have limit education access for Black girls with disabilities.For example, accommodations outlined in a student’s Individualized Education Plan (IEP) are often not provided due to delays in receiving IEPs from the student’s previous school or a given facility’s capacity limitations. Moreover, the National Center for Learning Disabilities has reported that it is common for juvenile detention centers to rewrite or alter IEPs to remove accommodations and services that the facility is “unable” to provide, without regard to the student's need. The “unjust use of restraint and seclusion”, which impacts Black girls in juvenile detention at rates much higher than girls of other races, also violates the right of students with disabilities to be educated in the “least restrictive environment.” 


Education does not thrive in detention, and the substandard education disabled students receive in juvenile detention puts them further behind their peers and at greater risk for continued or repeated system involvement.


Healthcare Access and Medical Neglect

As a population with higher and often more urgent healthcare needs, disabled Black women and girls are particularly impacted by jails and prisons that fail to address health concerns in an adequate and/or timely manner. In the National Black Women Justice Institute’s Pathways to Wellness study from 2023, formerly incarcerated Black women reported treatment delays, dismissed or minimized complaints, misdiagnoses, and expensive healthcare costs as aspects that negatively impacted their health during and after incarceration. To quote one participant, “medical staff has the tendency to push you off and try to deter you from seeking any type of medical treatment or service,” allowing conditions to worsen until “it’s at a point where the illness . . . has gone on for so long untreated that it’s progressed and . . . become more severe” than when the initial complaint was made. This aligns with findings from other studies investigating the experiences of incarcerated Black women and with the general phenomenon of Black women not being believed in medical settings and having to fight for appropriate testing and treatment.


Disability worsens the impact of unreliable and inaccessible healthcare systems in jails and prisons. For example, if a facility is unable to provide adequate care for someone with a high-needs disability, they might be placed in solitary confinement or sent to facilities much further from home, making it even harder to maintain a connection with their loved ones while detained. While incarcerated, Black women and girls with disabilities go without necessary treatment and medication and endure dismissive and condescending treatment by staff, including medical professionals, when they express their needs. This results in ongoing harm that worsens both their physical and mental health. Many have died due to this neglect, whether from physical ailments or by their own hand.



Solitary Confinement (or Segregation)

The harms of solitary confinement (also known as segregation, restricted housing, etc.) are well documented in research. The experience, which consists of spending at least 22 hours a day isolated without “meaningful human contact”, can result in irreparable damage across multiple dimensions of health. In addition to mental illnesses like depression and anxiety, solitary confinement has been linked to symptoms of psychosis, paranoia, and many other illnesses. It has an especially large impact on those with preexisting mental health conditions. Individuals who have spent time in solitary confinement are at elevated risk for suicide during their incarceration and after their release.There are also well documented racial disparities in solitary confinement placement. According to the 2021 Time-In-Cell report from Yale Law School, Black women are overrepresented in solitary confinement. They make up 20% of women in the prison custodial population, but 30% of women in restrictive housing. 


The limited research focusing on the experiences of women in solitary confinement has found that women are sent to solitary confinement for less serious violations than men (i.e., insubordination) and for behavioral infractions that result from mental illnesses or other disabilities. Interviews with women in solitary confinement highlight gender-specific difficulties, such as accessing clean clothes during menstruation. People with various physical disabilities similarly experience segregation in ways that inflict harm specific to them. For example, the size of the space limits movement, which can prevent them from being able to do necessary physical therapy exercises, thus further limiting mobility and, often, causing significant pain.


Black women, girls, and gender expansive people with disabilities are at heightened risk for solitary confinement for various reasons. First, just like outside, disabilities are policed and punished in carceral settings. Failure to heed directions, regardless of one’s ability to understand or comply, is a punishable offense that can lead to solitary confinement. Moreover, people with disabilities are also placed in solitary confinement due to there being no accessible housing placements available, medical isolation, and “protective” custody. In other words, a facility’s “inability” to adequately house, care for, or ensure the safety of disabled individuals can result in solitary confinement without a formal write-up.


Paths Forward

The United States incarcerates more of its population than nearly any other nation in the world, including those with similar or larger rates of crime. Ableism plays a critical role in populating American jails and prisons because it, like other systems of oppression, helps to mark and separate marginalized peoples. Ableist policing practices lead to disabled people being criminalized at higher rates. This is especially true for Black women, girls, and gender-expansive individuals with disabilities. An estimated 41.3% of Black women with disabilities are arrested at least by the age of 28.



While disabled people are most impacted by ableism, it is particularly dangerous because disability is an extraordinary tool of systemic oppression. Historically, it has been used to justify myriad harms: from unethical medical experimentation to “disappearing” people from public life. Scientific racism justified slavery, genocide, and white supremacy through falsified biological traits (smaller brains, race-specific illnesses, etc.) that marked non-white bodies as inferior: unfit and unable to participate in society as white people do. Similarly, sexism is predicated on the belief that women are biologically inferior, unequipped and unable to handle responsibilities like leadership and self-determination. Talila Lewis, an abolitionist whose extensive work about the experiences  of deaf/disabled people has contributed much to the disability justice movement, summarizes this well, stating that “ableism in the united states has never solely been about disability . . . [It] has always been about at least race, gender, labor/productivity/capital, and dis/ability.” 


It is this understanding that undergirds disability justice, a framework created by disabled queer activists in Sins Invalid. It is an inherently intersectional framework asserting that “all bodies are unique and essential . . . [and] all bodies have strengths and needs that must be met.” Applying a disability justice framework in our fight against the criminalization of Black women and girls requires that we uplift the experiences of the most impacted (among other things outlined in the ten principles of disability justice, which can be found here). Disabled Black women, girls, and gender expansive people are particularly vulnerable to criminalization and experience greater harms related to it. 


Get Involved

You can support our work by subscribing to our newsletter to receive updates about reports and resources that support system-impacted Black women and girls and by sharing this blog with your network.


If you are interested in making a donation, click here to support NBWJI’s work.


bottom of page